Appeal to the Nobler Motives

Part 3: How to Win People to Your Way of Thinking — Principle 19

“A person usually has two reasons for doing a thing: one that sounds good and a real one.” — J. Pierpont Morgan

Two Reasons for Every Action

J.P. Morgan, the great financier, made an observation that Carnegie found so fundamental he built an entire principle around it: every person has two reasons for doing what they do. There is the real reason—self-interest, habit, fear, desire—and there is the reason that sounds good, the one that the person would be comfortable saying out loud and that reflects well on them.

Most of us, most of the time, operate according to the real reason while explaining our behavior with the reason that sounds good. We skip the meeting because we don’t want to be there, but we tell ourselves (and others) that we had an urgent priority. We don’t call back because we’re avoiding a difficult conversation, but we cite being busy.

Carnegie’s insight is not that people are hypocrites. It is that people genuinely want to be the kind of person described by the reason that sounds good. The nobler motive is not entirely false; it is who the person wishes they were. And if you appeal to it—if you treat people as if they already have the noble character they wish they had—you often inspire them to live up to it.

The Power of Appealing High

When you ask someone to do something by appealing to their self-interest—“if you do this, you’ll benefit in these ways”—you are engaging with the real reason. This works, and Carnegie endorses it (Principle 3). But there is another, often more powerful, appeal: appealing to the person’s sense of their own character.

“I know you’re the kind of person who keeps their word.” “I know how much integrity means to you.” “I trust you to do the right thing here.” These statements are not flattery if you say them to someone who has shown those qualities, or even to someone who wants to possess them. They are invitations to be the person the speaker believes them to be.

The Nobler Motive in Action

When you need someone to act ethically, fairly, or generously:

  1. Identify the noble quality you want them to express: honesty, fairness, loyalty, courage
  2. Frame your request in terms of that quality: “I know fairness is important to you
” “You’ve always been someone who
”
  3. Make the action the natural expression of who they are: “That’s why I wanted to bring this to you—I knew you’d want to do the right thing here.”

This works not because it manipulates but because it genuinely activates the part of the person that wants to be noble. Most people, given the opportunity to be the hero of the story, will take it.

John D. Rockefeller and the Photographers

Carnegie tells the story of John D. Rockefeller Jr., who was under siege from newspaper photographers determined to photograph his children. Rather than threatening legal action or hiding, Rockefeller appealed to the photographers’ sense of themselves as decent men.

He acknowledged their professional need, expressed genuine understanding of it, and then appealed to their sense of fair play: “Gentlemen, you’ve been trying to get these pictures. I know it’s your job. But as fathers yourselves, you know what it would mean to have your own children subjected to this. These are just children who haven’t done anything to deserve this kind of attention. I’m asking you, as men who understand family, to let them be.”

The photographers put away their cameras. Rockefeller had not threatened or bribed or argued. He had appealed to the best version of who they were—fathers who understood the vulnerability of children. And they had chosen to be that person.

When the Noble Appeal Works Best

The nobler motive appeal is particularly powerful when:

Lord Northcliffe and the Newspaper

Carnegie tells the story of a newspaper proprietor named Lord Northcliffe who needed to stop a particular photograph of himself from being published. He could have threatened legal action. Instead, he wrote to the editor: “I understand you are thinking of publishing that photograph. I would rather you didn’t, but if you decide to, I ask only one thing—that you use the enclosed photograph instead of that one. The other photograph doesn’t represent me well, and I believe you’d want to use the one that’s more accurate.”

Northcliffe appealed to the editor’s professional pride in accuracy and fairness. He got the photograph he preferred published. He had not said “I’m powerful and you’d better not cross me.” He had said “I trust you to be the fair professional you are.”

The Practice: Finding the Nobler Motive

For any request you need to make of someone:

  1. What is the self-interest appeal? (What do they gain?)
  2. What is the nobler appeal? (What does doing this say about their character?)
  3. Which version of the appeal is more compelling—and more true—for this particular person?
  4. Frame your request in the language of the nobler motive: “I know you care about fairness
” “This is exactly the kind of thing I knew you’d want to do
”

Practice: The Noble Frame

For the next week, when you need to ask someone for a favor or persuade them to act:

  1. Write down both the self-interest reason and the noble reason for them to act
  2. Lead with the noble reason—framed in their values, not yours
  3. Notice whether people respond differently when you treat them as if they’re already the person they want to be

Reflection

Think of someone in your life who regularly falls short of their own stated values. Have you tried appealing to those values sincerely—genuinely treating them as if they already possess the character they wish they had? What might happen if you did?

Key Takeaways

← Previous: Chapter 18 Next: Chapter 20 →